margarine substitutes

fattendernessbrowning

Ingredientmargarine

fattendernessbrowningHigh confidenceMedium risk

The call

Use butter for margarine.

Use 1:1 by weight for most solid-fat swaps.

Ratio

1 : 1 by weight

Why

Butter, margarine, shortening, and similar fats track well when the recipe mainly needs tenderness or frying fat.

Flavor

Butter and animal fats taste more distinct than neutral shortenings.

Texture

Shortening produces a more tender, less flavorful result.

Alternatives, ranked

4 more options

CandidateRatioConfidenceRiskNotes
1unsalted butter1 : 1 by weightA·0.91MedSolid fats replace one another more cleanly than liquids replace solids.
2neutral oil3 : 4B·0.80MedOil replaces melted butter well but changes structure in creamed batters.
3salted butter1 : 1 by weightA·0.91MedSolid fats replace one another more cleanly than liquids replace solids.
4canola oil3 : 4B·0.80MedOil replaces melted butter well but changes structure in creamed batters.

Adjustments

salt
Reduce added salt when switching from unsalted to salted butter.

Where to be careful

  • Med
    butterLow in general cooking; medium in laminated doughs.
  • Med
    unsalted butterLow in general cooking; medium in laminated doughs.
  • Med
    neutral oilMedium in recipes that depend on creaming for lift.

Was this useful?